Role of vitamin E in pregnant women
BACKGROUND
Vitamin E is the term used for eight naturally occurring fat-soluble nutrients called tocopherols or tocotrienols, dependently of the chemical structure. alpha-Tocopherol is essential, has the highest biological activity and is found in all lipoprotein fractions and is associated with very-low-density lipoprotein (VLDL). Vitamin E is the most important lipid soluble antioxidant and deficiency during pregnancy may cause miscarriage, preterm birth, preeclampsia and intrauterine growth restriction (IUGR).
OBJECTIVE
This review highlights recent findings that have led to a better understanding of vitamin E absorption, transport, bioavailability and its role in pregnant women. This new information may be helpful for the evaluation of the potential benefits of vitamin E supplementation in pregnant women.
INTRODUCTION
There are eight forms of this lipophilic antioxidant: alpha-, beta-, gamma-, and delta-tocopherols and alpha-, beta-, gamma-, and delta-tocotrienols. With respect to tocopherols, although gamma-tocopherol is the major form of dietary vitamin E, alpha-tocopherol is the most important vitamin E form found in human plasma and tissues. The natural form of alpha-tocopherol is found in the RRR configuration and the synthetic alpha-tocopherol (all rac alpha-tocopherol) consists of an equal racemic mixture of the eight stereoisomer (RRR, RSR, RRS, RSS, SRR, SSR, SRS and SSS). The capacity to increase alpha-tocopherol concentrations in plasma is limited because alpha-tocopherol is replaced by newly absorbed alpha-tocopherol, the surplus being excreted in bile.
ORIGIN AND METABOLISM OF VITAMIN E
A. Intestinal absorption and plasma transport of vitamin E
The digestion of vitamin E in the small intestinal lumen is similar to that of dietary fats. Upon entering the circulation via the thoracic lymph, chylomicron triglycerides are hydrolysed by endothelium-bound lipoprotein lipase (LPL) resulting in the production of chylomicron remnants. At this point, fatty acids as well as some vitamin E molecules are then transferred to peripheral tissues. On the other hand, chylomicron remnants, carrying vitamin E, are then taken up by hepatic endocytosis. Within the liver, vitamin E is either excreted into the bile, metabolised to carboxyethyl-hydroxychroman (CEHC) and excreted into urine, or secreted back to plasma within VLDL.
B. Hepatic metabolism of vitamin E
Before secretion into the circulation via the VLDL pathway, the hepatic -tocopherol form of vitamin E is selected by the alpha-tocopherol transfer protein (alpha-TTP), a small cytoplasmic hepatic protein with differential affinity for vitamin E forms, and thus having the capacity of biodiscrimination. This protein is not only expressed in the liver but also in human brain and placenta.
C. Bioavailability
Bioavailability can be defined as the fraction of a food substance placed at the disposal of tissues after ingestion. This availability is essential for biological activity since only this fraction has a physiological activity. Vitamin E bioavailability depends also on its dispersion in the intestinal lumen and the co-ingestion of other fat components, namely fatty acids and plant sterols. Indeed, vitamin E bioavailability is greatest when administered with food. Some studies have observed that maternal vitamin E levels increased significantly during pregnancy despite the marked increase in plasma volume during pregnancy, suggesting that bioavailability may be increased in pregnant women.
D. Role of alpha-tocopherol
For many years, alpha-tocopherol has primarily been noted for its capacity to protect lipids and lipoproteins against peroxidative. However, alpha-tocopherol has other important biological functions, such as altering gene expression, modulating of cell signalling and proliferation. The alpha-tocopherol isoform of vitamin E inhibits radical chain propagation within lipid domains by its own conversion into an oxidized product, alpha-tocopherylquinone. It is increasingly clear that the balance between vitamin E and other antioxidants may be crucial for in vivo antioxidant protection. Indeed, the original form can be regenerated by reduction by ascorbate (vitamin C). Without this compound, alpha-tocopherol remains oxidized and is able to function as a pro-oxidant, i.e. it will able to oxidize lipoprotein. These observations do not contest a role for alpha-tocopherol as an antioxidant in vivo, given that, co-antioxidants such as ascorbate and ubiquinol-10, must be present in the vascular environment to convert alpha-tocopherol from a pro-oxidant into an antioxidant.
E. Role of gamma-tocopherol
gamma-Tocopherol can decrease platelet aggregation, delay time to occlusive thrombus, decrease arterial superoxide anion generation, lipid peroxidation and LDL oxidation, and increase endogenous SOD activity. gamma-Tocopherol and its metabolite also can reduce PGE2 synthesis, which plays a key role in inflammation. In addition, gamma-tocopherol is superior to alpha-tocopherol in controlling damage caused by reactive nitrogen oxide species and in reducing oxidative DNA damage.
F. Interactions between alpha- and gamma-tocopherol
After high-dose alpha-tocopherol administration, several studies have observed a decrease in gamma-tocopherol and during gamma-tocopherol administration, plasma concentration of alpha-tocopherol decreased significantly and urinary excretion of alpha-CEHC tended to increase.
VITAMIN E SUPPLEMENTATION
Vitamin E supplementation results in variable increases in plasma alpha-tocopherol concentrations. Such variations may result from differences in, alpha-TTP activity, metabolic rate, lipid content and composition, the status of other micronutrients that recycle alpha-tocopherol, and environmental conditions. Vitamin E supplementation has been reported to be safe for most adults in amounts less than 1600 IU and to prevent oxidative stress which is associated with many diseases such as injury, trauma, sepsis, ischemia, or severe inflammation. However, two studies have suggested that more than 400 IU/day of vitamin E may increase the risk of all-cause mortality and heart failure, whereas Bjelakovic et al have reported that antioxidant supplements for primary and secondary prevention of several diseases, including atherosclerosis, may increase mortality. On the other hand, Chappell et al reported that antioxidant supplementation in women who were at risk of preeclampsia was associated with improvement in biochemical indices of the disease.
VITAMIN E AND PREGNANCY
As an antioxidant, vitamin E contributes to limit oxidative stress but this vitamin is also an indispensable nutrient for reproduction. Indeed, female rats fed on a vitamin E free diet are sterile, and impaired fertility is also observed in animals lacking the alpha-TTP, suggesting that vitamin E may play an important role in human reproduction. Furthermore, it is suggested that alpha-TTP plays a major role in supplying the placenta and consecutively the foetus with alpha-tocopherol during pregnancy. During normal pregnancy, the plasma alpha-tocopherol concentration increases but in abnormal pregnancies, blood alpha-tocopherol concentrations are lower than those in normal pregnancies at a corresponding gestational age.
VITAMIN E SUPPLEMENTATION AND PREECLAMPSIA
Theoretically, supplements of vitamins C and E might prevent diseases such as preeclampsia because of their multiple actions in addition to prevention of lipid peroxidation. However, this effect has not been validated in clinical practice. While Chappell et al found some beneficial effects, Poston et al failed to confirm such a protective role of vitamin supplementation in a larger study. Furthermore, an increase in low birth weight babies was observed among pregnancies exposed to vitamin supplementation. Similarly, Beazley et al and Rumbold et al, no reduction in preeclampsia risk was noted with vitamin E supplementation. Rodrigo et al have suggested that the failure to observe a protective effect may be due to the fact that the initiation of the treatment was after the critical phase of placentation (14 and 22 weeks of gestation). Polyzos et al have concluded that the available evidence does support the use of combined vitamin C and E supplementation during pregnancy for the prevention of preeclampsia, whereas the safety of such supplementation vis-à-vis infant outcome is at least questionable. Differences in observations and conclusions may be due to the vitamin E bioavailability which differs between women or other factors such as the form of vitamin E used in supplementation. Indeed, when alpha-tocopherol administration increased, studies have observed a decrease in gamma-tocopherol and the later may be superior to alpha-tocopherol to controlling oxidation. Moreover, many studies have not determined vitamin E levels by HPLC analysis. Because vitamin E bioavailability change depending many factors and because we don’t really know if women took the pill everyday, it’s essential to measure the real plasmatic concentration of vitamin E before concluding.
NEW KNOWLEDGE AND CHALLENGES REMAIN TO BE ADDRESSED
While vitamin E is essential for reproduction, the optimal dose has not been determined. In order to study the effects of exposure to vitamin E, studies that correlate plasma and tissue levels to physiological indicators are required. It is possible that vitamin E supplementation would be necessary only when the bioavailability is decreased. Further research is needed for vitamin E supplementation either alone or in combination with supplements during pregnancy will be beneficial or not for the maternal and infant health. Several recent studies evaluating alpha-tocopherol supplementation have failed to show a protective effect and, in some studies, adverse effects were observed. Also, it has been noted that supplementation with alpha-tocopherol decreases the levels of gamma-tocopherol. Now that we know physiological effects associated with the gamma- form, it is suggest that the supplementation with alpha-tocopherol is not appropriate. Moreover, it is possible that alpha-tocopherol supplementation could result in pro-oxidant effects, especially if alpha-tocopherol concentration were already high. Further studies are required to answer these questions.
TRANSDISCIPLINARY APPROACH/TRANSFER KNOWLEDGE
This review will be very useful for scientists in several fields. Indeed, the biochemical aspect is discussed when the metabolism of vitamin E is explained. As for the clinical aspects, it will be very useful for health professionals which to know a little more about vitamin E supplements. Finally, the epidemiological aspect is very important because it allows us to make an analysis of previous studies to verify the efficiency of vitamin E and it permits to design further research. This review has been accepted for publication in the Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology Canada.
QUESTIONS
-What is your opinion about vitamin E supplementation in pregnant women?
-Do you have any ideas about future studies to be done to answer questions regarding the gamma-tocopherol form?
- Vous devez vous connecter pour poster des commentaires




Thank you, It is a very
Thank you,
It is a very interesting topic as we all sort of thought that treating oxidative stress will be beneficial. After seeing the results of the recent clinical studies we may think that oxidative stress is physiological and the tissue/placenta can manage some extra stress. It is always a question what is the primary cause and what is the result. In this case the signs of oxidative stress may be a sign of the tissue coping with a condition and not necessarily a pathology by itself.
Thanks
Ori Nevo
Dear, Thank you for your
Dear,
Thank you for your interesting comment.
I agree with you about the fact that oxidative stress may be not necessarily a pathology by itself but a sign of the tissue coping with a condition.
For example, in preeclampsia, a number of studies indicate that oxidative stress could be a significant component of the disease. However, this disease could also be associated with endothelial dysfunction and disorder in the production of vasoactive eicosanoids such as thromboxane A2 (TXA2), a potent vasoconstrictor, and prostacyclin (PGI2), a well-known vasodilatator. There is a strong relationship between the oxidative stress observed in preeclampsia and the altered production of vasoactive eicosanoids in preeclampsia suggesting that oxidative stress is not alone in the establishment of the disease.
However, since preeclampsia is diagnosed after the establishment of the clinical symptoms, it is unclear whether an imbalance between prooxidants and antioxidants occurs prior or during the development of this pathology.
We know that oxidative stress results from an imbalance between production of free radicals and antioxidant protection. Do you think that vitamin E supplementation (antioxidant) is a good solution to control oxidative stress in preeclampsia?
Thanks again,
Amélie Gagné
Hi All, As the facilitator
Hi All,
As the facilitator for this section, I am finding the discussion very interesting. Oxidative stress is such a broad term for such a complex system. As noted in the summary and the discussions, by definition, oxidative stress is an imbalance of prooxidants and antioxidants. I agree that oxidative stress may be a response as the cells cope with an adverse environment. But I agree with Amelie that it is more likely to result in cellular dysfunction which could either cause some of the symptoms observed in women with preeclampsia or may create a feed forward system that exacerbates the vascular complication. In addition, it is important to note that different cell types and compartmentalization within cells will dictate the response observed. For instance greater superoxide anion production in endothelial cells may scavenge the potent vasodilator nitric oxide thus leading to less vascular relaxation. On the other hand, superoxide anion can be converted to hydrogen peroxide which is a vasodilator. So the system in complex. The idea of supplementing women with vitamin E to control "oxidative stress" in preeclampsia may be an oversimplified approach for a complex system. It will be important to identify key pathways in the process leading to oxidant stress and perhaps target the upstream factors that promote the cellular oxidant stress.
Keep up the interesting discussions!
Sandy Davidge
Thank you Amélie, Vitamin E
Thank you Amélie,
Vitamin E supplementation is an interesting topic and still subject to debate. Clinical studies, like you mention in your review, show a variety of responses (nothing, a little and in some case bad effects). To confirm or not positive effect of the supplementation, the better form of vitamin E (alpha and/or gamma tocopherol) and the good combination with other vitamin such as vitamin C or other molecules must be studied. On the other hand, in industrial country where women have a diet relatively well balanced may be it is not necessary to supplement diet with vitamin E, contrary to deprived population.
To better understand the effect of vitamin E on trophoblastic cells and in oxydative stress, in vitro studies must be done. I do a rapid pub med search and I just find one study with primary cells from placenta, they show anti-oxydant role of vitamin E in combination with vitamin C (Cindrova-Davies T et al, 2007). It seems there is no study of the effect of gamma-tocopherol on trophoblastic cells. There are studies in ohter cell types and in other pathology. Do you know if there is some information on the specific role vitamin E on trophoblastic cells in vitro?
Frederique Le Bellego
Thank you for your very
Thank you for your very interesting question!
It has not well understood when or where vitamin E is required during pregnancy. Moereover, the exact mechanisms on the specific role of vitamin E is uncertain. However, Jishage et al have shown that alpha-tocopherol may be important for the variability of syncytiotrophoblast cells in the labyrinthine region of the mouse placenta, and Kaempf-Rotzoll et al indicated that alpha-tocopherol plays a role in the process of implantation and that alpha-tocopherol transfer protein (alpha-TTP) may be necessary for adequate alpha-tocopherol status of the foetus. In addition, Jishage et al have suggested that oxidative stress in the labyrinth region of the placenta is decreased by vitamin E during placental development and that in, addition to the hepatic alpha-TTP, the uterine alpha-TTP may also play an important role.
Thanks,
Amélie Gagné
Frederique, You are raising
Frederique,
You are raising an interesting question regarding the role of vitamin C. This hypotehsis is based on the fact that vitamin E (lipophilic molecule) is carried by lipoproteins whereas vitamin C (hydrophilic molecule) is found in plasma. Consequently, the free radicals are thus transfered from oxidized lipids to vitamnin E and, secondly, from vitamin E to vitamin C to be eliminated by kidneys.
In a recent paper in press in Metabolism, we have studied the effect of environmental contaminants, such as mercury and PCBs, on the oxidation of vitamin E and C in male and female adults. We have found the the first response to oxidative stress was given by CoQ10 (ubiquinol-10) also carried by lipoproteins, not by vitamin E or C.
Thus in preeclampsia should we favor an increase in the levels of COQ-10 instead of vitamin E and/or C? Or would increases in oxidized vitamin E be the result of low levels of CoQ10 and ineffective protection by CoQ10?
Pierre Julien
STIRRHS's mentor
Hi Amelie, Thank you for
Hi Amelie,
Thank you for your review - it was very interesting. I am wondering, given the section you wrote on challenges and new directions for research, what your ideal study design would be (assuming you had endless resources such as time and money) to look at the questions you raised (such as the optimal dose of vitamin E in reproduction, the relationship between supplementation and bioavailability, etc.) I'm just wondering where your mind is going in terms of future research projects...
I was also interested to note your comment about some of the limitations of previous studies looking at supplementation, particularly the piece about not knowing whether women are actually taking the supplements as recommended. Have their been studies that have controlled for this or have you yourself thought about looking at this aspect in order to clarify the literature.
Any thoughts would be welcome.
Thanks again for sharing your review with us,
Alex.
Hi Alex, Thank you for your
Hi Alex,
Thank you for your interest.
Few studies have made determination of plasmatic vitamin E and that’s the problem. We know that there is bioavailability change from one person to another and that depending food consumed, women may have initially, more or less vitamin E concentration. It is therefore essential to provide assay of plasma vitamin E when we want to study the possible effect of this antioxidant. This confirms even though women have taken their tablets. Moreover, it may be possible that women take vitamins, but if there is an assimilation problem or other, determination of concentration allows us to verify.
Regarding my views on future research projects, obviously should, in addition to having a dietary questionnaire, that plasma concentrations were verified by HPLC. The questionnaire diet is important because it is possible that women consume vitamin E via food. Moreover, it was shown that the absorption of vitamin E is promoted when the meal that accompanies it is rich in fat.
It should be determine plasma concentrations of vitamin E in women before supplementation. First, in order to determine whether they need to be supplemented because we saw that higher vitamin E concentration is not desirable because vitamin E could become a pro-oxidant molecule. Secondly, the supplements doses should be based on patients’ plasma concentration at the outset. Ideally, it would be interesting to take blood samples from women during supplementation to verify if women have a good assimilation and if vitamin doses are sufficient.
Of course, during the study, it would be interesting to try different vitamin E plasma levels in order to ascertain what would be ideal concentration.
Finally, knowing that we shouldn’t administer vitamin E alone, it would be interesting to see whether giving of coenzyme Q10, instead of vitamin C, or in addition to vitamin C is better. As Dr. Julien said, it was suggested that coenzyme Q10 might be the first respondent in oxidative stress. In this case, it would be much more useful to use this antioxidant. I would therefore propose to undertake a study on this. Again, I believe that dosage is very important. There should be tests to see the ideal dose… which means, again, that we should measure antioxidant plasmatic concentrations by HPLC.
Thanks,
Amélie
Hi Amelie, Thank you for
Hi Amelie,
Thank you for your response. You clarified a number of things for me and I was interested to read about your thoughts on research design. I agree that a dietary questionnaire to assess food intake with vitamin E would be an important piece.
Thanks again,
Alex.
Hi Amelie, Thank you for the
Hi Amelie,
Thank you for the review. I learned quite a bit having not studied pregnancy but mechanisms to prevent pregnancy.
I have a couple questions. In the studies you mentioned how were the vitamin E forms administered? Was the vitamin E administration on top of the participants taking prenatal vitamins? Prenatal vitamins have vitamin E and C in them, have any researchers worked on changing the levels and type of vitamin E in this form? What type of vitamin E is currently found in prenatal vitamins?
You have probably already thought of this and decided it was not the most efficient way of answering the question but most women do take the prenatal vitamins and make taking them an important part of their lives, do they not? It seems then that the best way to work the gamma form into future studies would be to alter the current forms of prenatal vitamins to include the gamma form or more of the gamma form.
Thanks again for sharing your review, it was a very interesting read on the other side of my research story.
Heather
Hi Heather, Thanks for
Hi Heather,
Thanks for questions.
I’m not familiar with prenatal vitamins but in Centrum Materna, for example, we find about 30 IU of vitamin E. There is no indication, but it is probably in alpha-tocopherol form because it is what is generally given. Often, in studies, we have 400 IU of vitamin E. In these studies, we noticed a significant increase in vitamin E, but this increase is limited due to the fact that vitamin E is renewed frequently. In prenatal vitamins, vitamin E concentrations are very low. This will increase plasma concentrations, but not so noticeable.
Regarding the making of g-tocopherol instead of a-tocopherol, I’m not against the idea, since new research suggests that gamma-tocopherol could may be more effective than alpha-tocopherol. However, it is very easy to find gamma-tocopherol in food everyday. In this case, would it not be better to promote these foods, rather than taking supplements?
Thank you for your interest,
Amélie
Hi Amelie, The discussions
Hi Amelie,
The discussions have been interesting and the most recent comments suggest continuing Vitamin E but either monitoring levels or include the gamma form or perhaps incorporate coenzyme Q10. My question is about ethics. In Canada, we stopped the Vitamin E/C trial in light of negative data from the large trial in the UK (Poston et al). Thus how do you think we proceed? Would you be able to get ethics approval and/or convince women to enter new trials in this area?
Sandy Davidge
STIRRHS Mentor and Facilitor
Dear, Thank you for your
Dear,
Thank you for your comment.
In the study of Poston et al., the problem is that they have not measured the vitamin E blood levels. So, I come back on the same basis that it is difficult to know the actual amount that a patient can have, as each person responds differently to supplements. It is clear that we must take any risks. It’s a good thing to stop a study when we think it is harmful. However, in this case, I think we need to see if having babies smaller birth weight (article in attachment) is really due to vitamin E. I think it is not possible to conclude before having plasma concentrations.
I’m currently analyze concentrations of plasma vitamin E (INTAPP study), and I can see very well how patients react differently. Not all supplemented women have higher vitamin E concentrations. Moreover, some controls (not supplemented) have higher vitamin E concentrations than supplemented women. In this case, how can we say that side effects, observed in Poston et al. study, were really caused by vitamin E supplementation? I think it would be better to compared mothers with their plasma concentrations, and not just by the fact they are taking supplements or not.
An initial study on a possible link between vitamin E and smaller birth weight could be done in animal models. If there is no correlation and if results obtained with INTAPP study suggest different results from Poston et al, probably we will convince ethics committees, as well as future patients.
Hoping to have answered your question,
Amélie
Thank you. You have raised a
Thank you. You have raised a number of excellent points and I think the overall take home message is that more research is needed!!
Sandy
Hi Amelie, I’ve found your
Hi Amelie,
I’ve found your review very complete and I learned a lot on the subject. Thank you. I would like to know want is the primary goal of your INTAPP study. Is it a study on the effect of vitamin E supplementation on the prevention of pre-eclampsia in women at risk (I.e.: like the Poston study)? I think that you are quite right to say that to plasma level of vitamin E are more accurate than intake to assess risk on individuals, but wouldn’t the conclusions (no prevention of pre-eclampsia as well as an increase rate of low birthweight in the offspring of treated mothers) be the same for a large population, regardless of individual plasmatic values? Do you know if plasma concentration of vitamin E in pre-eclamptic women with outcome in untreated (less than 400 UI) women?
Thanks,
Eric
Hi Eric, Thank you for
Hi Eric,
Thank you for questions.
Yes the aim of INTAPP study is to study the effect of vitamin E (and C) supplementation on the prevention of preeclampsia in women at risk like the Poston study. It’s the reason why results will be interesting.
Concerning your question about untreated women, in another study, we showed that plasma total vitamin E levels are higher in preeclampsia. We found that this higher level of vitamin E could be the consequence of the enhanced antioxidant defense in response to oxidative stress in women with preeclampsia.
In the present report, it is worth noting that increased levels of plasma total vitamin E in preeclampsia do not correspond to the imbalance in the oxidized/reduced form or to an increased concentration of oxidized vitamin E in preeclampsia. The latter supports the hypothesis of an enrichment of reduced vitamin E in LDL particles that could enhance antioxidant protection in preeclampsia.
The lower levels of reduced CoQ10 (ubiquinol-10 levels) found in women with preeclampsia are in agreement with the concept that lipophilic antioxidants, such as alpha-tocopherol and carotenoids, are more slowly affected by the oxidative stress than ubiquinol-10, suggesting that ubiquinol-10 could be one of the most sensitive indicator of oxidative stress.
Thanks,
Amélie
I enjoyed this great,
I enjoyed this great, concise and thought-provoking review and the comments!
From the fetal physiology standpoint I am wondering
- what could be the possible causal link between LBW neonates in mothers who received VitE supplement?
- if alpha-TTP is found in fetal brain and/or other organs;
- what is known about (differential) plancetal transfer & effects of alpha- & gamma-tocopherol in the fetus during the 1-3 trimester?
- looking at the former in the light of fetal inflammation status might be interesting in terms of modulation of ongoing ROS production
Perhaps, some of this might be part of another review.
All the best for the future and
Thank you,
Martin
Thank you all for this
Thank you all for this discussion. It was really interesting.
It's nice to talk with people from other areas because it allows us to see our project from another point of view.
This activity will allow me to finish writing my master with lots of new ideas on topics to be addressed. First, I think it will be interesting to address the issue of ethics when I speak of future studies. In expressing my opinions, I believe that readers will understand that it might be possible to rebuild further studies on vitamin E supplementation, despite Poston et al. study.
Thanks,
Amélie